A Season of Promises,
Writer: Michael Grimm
Director: Stacey N. Harding
Cast: Brooke D'Orsay, Ali Liebert, James Denton, Eddie Ruttle, Kate Dion, Catherine Lough Haggquist, Barclay Hope, Graeme McComb, Laura Soltis, Dolores Drake, Marion Eisman, Anna Hagan
Brooke D'Orsay (Oy to the World!) and Ali Liebert (Three Wisest Men) play sisters Heidi and Sophie. Heidi is a hard working, rule-following local (?) hockey ... reporter (?) who is eyeing a promotion. Sophie is a waitress and stand-up comedian who's keeping the open mic stages hot even as winter sets in — and that's when her boyfriend set the "hit the big time or I bounce" ultimatum. Whatever — she doesn't need him! Heidi and Sophie are also estranged from each other following the death of their mother a few years prior. But after their dad Ed (James Denton, A Grand Ole Opry Christmas) experiences a health scare, Heidi and Sophie are brought back into each other's lives.
Oh — and they discover a message from their mother from beyond the grave! Okay, it's not that spooky. They just find a video message that their mother recorded while she was sick urging her daughters to help their father find love again after she's gone.
Now it's up to Heidi and Sophie to fix their problems so they can help fill their dad's lonely life. Maybe he needs some love, sure, but I bet he also needs his daughters to be able to be in the same room again.
Home for the Holidays: Like nearly every other Hallmark movie, we're in good old Colorado — specifically Highridge. Highridge isn't a real city, mind you, but it is the name of a park near Aurora.
A Holiday Tradition: As far as Ed and his daughters are concerned, Christmas and all of its traditions ceased when the family matriarch passed away. Now Heidi only engages in local traditions that she's forced to cover (like a snowman building contest). Sophie goes to holiday open mics at the High Brow Comedy Club, but you know she'd be there no matter what the theme was.
Presence Under the Tree: Okay, can we talk about Eddie Ruttle, who plays nurse Brad, a.k.a. Sophie's love interest? He is the textbook example of a cutie. The stubble, the smile, the goofy charm — also, I love seeing a short king as a Hallmark hunk. I don't know — I rarely get jealous when a Hallmark leading lady kisses their man for the first time, but I kinda did here? He's adorable and deserves leading man status next year.
Ho Ho Ho: It's a tall order when you put an aspiring stand-up in your story. Unfortunately Sophie doesn't really bring the jokes here. It's actually Brad, telling a made-over Ed to "trust the paste, sir" (re: hair product) that made me chuckle.
Sl-A.I.-gh Ride: Yeah, I'm going to be keeping an eye out for any and all suspicious looking A.I. generated slop this season. The logos for everything, the hockey team and the comedy club, have that uncanny valley, slightly outdated, basic design and typography that you expect from A.I., which is evil and actively killing the Earth.
Exactly As Advertised: I don't understand why this is called A Season of Promises. There is only one promise in the whole movie (hook your dad up with dates, kids!), not a whole season of them. Maybe if the mom gave them a checklist? Something like Mom's Christmas Wish would have worked better.
My first Hallmark review of the season and it has to be the one that is explicitly and exclusively about grief. Thanks, Hallmark! If you're in a certain state of mind, these movies really know how to get to you, and I've been in that state of mind for almost three straight years now. So ... this wasn't as fun of a watch as I'd hoped.
But it is to A Season of Promises' credit that the sentimentality and handling of grief never felt manipulative. It felt real, and at times raw (especially in the final act). Some character motivations needed another pass, like the inciting incident between Sophie and Heidi's feud. It's not as much fun as you want from a Hallmark movie, but it is well-performed, well-shot, and just might get the job done if you're looking for some catharsis this holiday season.
Hit Or Miss: This is subjective (as all reviews are, duh), but it just barely miss for me because, right now, I'm not in the emotional place for an old Hallmark Movies & Mysteries (R.I.P.) style drama. I want a romcom. So call this a NEAR MISS.









