Thanksgiving may as well have been invented for sitcoms. Wherever it may fall on your personal list of fave days, it's hard to argue that it's not the perfect holiday for TV comedies. For one, the people that you spend the holiday with mean something — something great, good, bad, whatever it is, it's storytelling gold. The celebrating itself involves hosting and cooking, usually for way too many people. And then there's the cooking — it's straight-up comical how hard it is to cook a turkey, and how we have all agreed that this impossible bird is the one we have to have on this day.
Think about it: Thanksgiving is an incredibly high stakes situation that scrutinizes what people mean to each other, wherein one (or more) people are burdened with doing something that is objectively one of the hardest tasks a human can undertake. Also, there are guest stars. It's the stuff that sitcoms are made of, and that's probably why there are so many T-gives episodes of so many shows.
So, as we all brace ourselves for our own Thanksgiving misadventures, Pop Heist has prepared a definitive, exhaustive list of the greatest Thanksgiving sitcom episodes of all time.
50. How I Met Your Mother, "Slapsgiving" (2007)
In "Slapsgiving," Marshall (Jason Segel) vows to use one of the five slaps he won in a bet with Barney (Neil Patrick Harris) — on Thanksgiving. How I Met Your Mother contributed a new riff on Thanksgiving with this episode, with a tradition that hopefully your family does not follow. That would be a signal major disfunction ("Maj. Disfunction").
49. Perfect Strangers, "Wild Turkey" (1991)
Larry (Mark Linn-Baker) comes up with a truly harebrained scheme — especially considering his role as the show's straight man. He's come into over a dozen live turkeys and he's gonna make bank selling them for Thanksgiving. Problem: one of the turkeys gobbles up his wife's wedding ring! You're not going to get well-written jokes on Perfect Strangers, and there's a sweatiness to watching the seventh season of a show that primarily relies on physical comedy, but its charm is kinda irresistible.
48. Everybody Loves Raymond, "No Fat" (1998)
The Barones' Thanksgiving is thrown into chaos when Marie (Doris Roberts) takes an uncharacteristic culinary risk and decides to make a healthy dinner. Truly, is there anything more '90s than the immediate and total revulsion to even the suggestion of tofu?
47. Living Single, "Thanks for Giving" (1994)
The gang's Thanksgiving dinner is torn along gender lines after Scooter (Cress Williams) asks Khadijah (Queen Latifah) to ... let him go on months-long PR tour. Not exactly the question she wanted him to pop. Beyond Living Single's already stacked ensemble, this episode features the aforementioned Williams, Heavy D, and Deion Sanders in a fourth-wall-breaking cameo.
46. Mad About You,"Riding Backwards" (1992)
Paul (Paul Reiser) and Jamie (Helen Hunt) take the Metro-North train to their family Thanksgiving. That's it as far as plot, but it's more than enough considering how this series turned truly nothing into fast-paced patter. Plus, you can't go wrong with a performance from a young Richard Kind, decades before his status as New York City's favorite goofily curmudgeonly uncle.
45. Reba, "Thanksgiving" (2004)
Reba's status as the queen of Thanksgiving is threatened when her ex-husband's wife (Hallmark holiday icon Melissa Peterman) steps up to host. We, as a society, do not talk enough about how downright delightful Reba McEntire is, and also how funny she is.
44. Coach, "It Came From New York" (1993)
Coach Hayden's (Craig T. Nelson) daughter Kelly (Clare Carey) comes home for Thanksgiving after moving to New York City, bringing with her a bunch of expensive gifts and plenty of names to drop. Much like in real life, Thanksgiving frequently inspires incredibly awkward and at times tough family reckonings in the lives of fictional sitcom characters. This is one of those times ... just set aside the credibility of Kelly climbing the corporate ladder so quickly in a job outside of her field. Man, that '90s economy sure was something.
43. Who's the Boss?, "Thanksgiving at Mrs. Rossini's" (1985)
Tony (Tony Danza) takes Angela (Judith Light) to a genuine Brooklyn Thanksgiving at — and is promptly set up on a blind date. I mean, Angela is right there, Mrs. Rossini! Read the room! But it's Mona (Katherine Helmond) who steals this episode with her brief appearance as a sexy Christmas bombshell. Helmond was 56 when this was filmed! What a legend!
42. Brooklyn Nine-Nine, "Mr. Santiago" (2016)
Jake (Andy Samberg) over prepares for his first encounter with Amy's (Melissa Fumero) overbearing, imposing father (Jimmy f'ing Smits). The A-plot is, of course, solid; you can't go wrong with casting Smits as an ex-cop and pairing him on a Thanksgiving day case with Samberg. But the B-plot, which pits Nine-Nine's excellent ensemble against a live turkey, is delicious comedy.
41. Family Ties, "No Nukes is Good Nukes" (1982)
The Keaton family's Thanksgiving dinner is ruined when mom and dad (Meredith Baxter, Michael Gross) are arrested for participating in a protest against nuclear weapons. Nothing speaks to the cyclical nature of politics and the pendulum swing of generations like Family Ties, a show that was incredibly of-the-moment in the '80s (hippie parents vs. yuppie, conservative kid), incredibly dated for the next 30 years, and now suddenly (scarily?) relevant again. Swap nukes for No Kings and, well, this is a 2026 Thanksgiving special.
40. The Simpsons, "Bart vs. Thanksgiving" (1990)
Feminist icon Lisa Simpson (Yeardley Smith) crafts a handmade, inspirational Thanksgiving centerpiece — only to see it go up in flames because of her bratty brother Bart (Nancy Cartwright). Bart then runs away from home after being cursed with the title of Ruiner of Thanksgiving.
39. Mama's Family, "An Ill Wind" (1986)
The Harper family Thanksgiving gets an unexpected guest: a darn tornado ripping through Raytown! Mama (Vicki Lawrence) and them end up locked in the basement, getting blitzed on Aunt Effie's homemade rum balls.
38. Modern Family,"Three Turkeys" (2014)
Jay and Gloria come up with the perfect plan to bail on another hectic Pritchett family gathering: stage a video call from their "vacation" in "Mexico" and then enjoy a peaceful staycation. That plan is ruined when the festivities unexpectedly move to Jay and Gloria's presumably empty home. Chaos ensues, as it should for every sitcom that features an ensemble as tight as this one.
37. How I Met Your Mother, "Slapsgiving 2: Revenge of the Slap" (2009)
The rare sequel that's better than the original, "Slapsgiving 2" wins because the slap plot is paired with an emotionally resonant A-plot involving Marshall trying to repair Lily's (Alyson Hannigan) relationship with her truly heinous father (Chris Elliott, in his first appearance on this list).
36. Full House, "The Miracle of Thanksgiving" (1987)
Before the avalanche of catch phrases, before Steve, before "ous queem," before the Ace of Base cover, before Uncle Jesse's sexy music video, there was just Full House: a sitcom about three dudes trying to raise three girls. And that's what this episode is: the three amigos trying to keep the girls' moods light on the first Thanksgiving after their mom's death. And what starts as light hijinks (a cooking montage set to a Motown classic) turns emotionally wrenching when the tragic reality of this moment hits. John Stamos goes for it, man.
35. Roseanne, "Thanksgiving 1991" (1991)
It's a shame that the legacy of Roseanne (the show) is overshadowed by the lunacy of Roseanne (the person), because this was far more than just one of many sitcoms handed to stand-ups in the late '80s. Roseanne was frequently groundbreaking and experimental, pushing the boundaries of what a sitcom could talk about, joke about, or look like. Take "Thanksgiving 1991," a prime example of Roseanne's freeform structure. There are no stories in this, per se. It's just an episode that perfectly captures how claustrophobic, disappointing, and upsetting Thanksgiving can be. This Thanksgiving episode feels like a real Thanksgiving.
34. Bewitched, "Samantha's Thanksgiving to Remember" (1967)
When forgetful Aunt Clara (Marion Lorne) accidentally transports the Stephens family (plus nosy neighbor Gladys Kravitz!) back to the 17th century, it's Darrin (Dick York) who's put on trial for witchcraft after he's heard saying the pagan phrase, "Hi there. Everything okay?" Bewitched always went hard for the holidays (Santa Claus is a recurring character on this show), and the show always leaned into the witches-as-minority metaphor in a frequently clunky but always well-meaning way. This time, the show uses a literal witch hunt to skewer McCarthyism and prejudice in a mock trial scenario.
33. Brooklyn Nine-Nine, "Two Turkeys" (2017)
After overcoming the awkwardness of meeting Amy's dad (see #42), Jake Peralta now has to make his mom and dad palatable for Jimmy Smits. Thanksgiving episodes give sitcoms a chance to go ham with stunt casting the relatives of series regulars, and this one really delivers with Katey Sagal and Bradley Whitford as Jake's rough-around-the-edges parents.
32. Bob's Burgers, "The Quirkducers" (2016)
In an attempt to get their Thanksgiving break started early, Louise cooks up a plan to get the annual turkey day pageant canceled. It's easy: just turn Tina's Thanksgiving fanfic into a musical, complete with turkey innards and blood. Lots of blood. You'll be singing, "I've got the guts, do you have the guts to be yourself?"
31. The Drew Carey Show, "Mimi's Day Parade" (1996)
With barely a week's notice, Drew (Drew Carey) gets stuck wrangling Winfred-Louder's first-ever Thanksgiving Day parade. In order to secure the fleet of flatbed trucks he needs, he makes a deal with the devil, a.k.a. his work nemesis, the walking Deee-Lite music video named Mimi (Kathy Kinney). In true Drew fashion, this one goes fully over-the-top (see: the Buzz Beer float, above) and features Happy Days' Tom Bosley as Mimi's father and — in quite possibly the most apt stunt casting of the '90s — Tammy Faye Messner as Mimi's mother.
30. Home Improvement, "The Wood, The Bad and the Hungry" (1996)
Tim ices his moocher friend Benny (Jim Labriola) out of the Taylor family Thanksgiving ... and then immediately regrets it when he sees Benny getting a meal at the local soup kitchen. These pangs of guilt lead to — what else? — a stop motion stylized dream wherein everyone from neighbor Wilson to sidekick Al get Rankin/Bass makeovers.
29. Bob's Burgers, "An Indecent Thanksgiving Proposal" (2012)
No sitcom patriarch loves Thanksgiving as much as Bob Belcher (H. Jon Benjamin), which is why he's put through the wringer every single year. The first of Bob's Thanksgiving episodes finds the Belchers roped into a con by their sociopathic landlord, Mr. Fischoeder (Kevin Kline). All they have to do is pose as his family (and Bob as his chef) for one meal and they get months of free rent, but that's a tall order when bribery, jealousy, deceit, and one bottle of absinthe are on the menu. Bonus: Linda (John Roberts) pens the 21st century's greatest Thanksgiving tune ("Pass! Tha cran-ber-ry sauce we're havin' mashed PAH-TAY-TAS!").
28. Newhart, "Thanksgiving For The Memories" (1986)
Some faulty wiring leaves the Stratford Inn without power on Thanksgiving, which sends Dick (Bob Newhart) and Joanna (Mary Frann) in search of a dinner worthy of Dick's new set of carving knives (and no, a Velveeta and mayo sandwich does not cut it). Things conclude at the Minuteman Cafe, where a meaty — yet highly questionable — dinner is served by Larry, Darryl, and Darryl.
27. Alice, "Who Ordered the Hot Turkey?" (1978)
Diner scrooge Mel (Vic Tayback) scores a bunch of live turkeys for cheap, unaware that they're stolen goods. Making matters worse, he ends up turkey-less just in time for his star-making spot on the evening news, wherein he's supposed to serve turkey to a busload of orphans. This one features a murderers' row of guest stars (James Cromwell, Corey Feldman, Joyce Bulifant) and the dynamic comedy duo of Beth Howland (as sweet, gullible Vera) and a turkey.
26. Frasier, "A Lilith Thanksgiving" (1996)
Admittedly, the A plot wherein Frasier (Kelsey Grammer) and Lilith (Bebe Neuwirth) desperately try to get their son admitted to an elite school on Thanksgiving Day stretches believability, even for a sitcom episode. What makes this one a winner is the bare bones B plot wherein Niles (David Hyde Pierce) and Martin (John Mahoney) repeatedly injure young Frederick (Trevor Einhorn). His delivery of, "I've got pills for everything" is relatable content for a generation of millennials who were once bowl cut-sporting sick kids.
25. Everybody Loves Raymond, "The Bird" (2003)
An awkward destination Thanksgiving goes from barely bearable to actively hostile when a tiny bird crashes headfirst into the home of Robert's (Brad Garrett) in-laws — and the MacDougall matriarch (Georgia Engel) uses her bare hands to put the bird out of its misery. The misanthropic Barones are surprisingly offended, and the aggressively holy MacDougalls — led by the iconic Fred Willard and the sugary sweet mania of the one and only Georgia Engel — fight back with laser-focused insight/insults. The first half of this episode is comedic perfection, but the second half's poor taste Thanksgiving pageant keeps this from placing higher.
24. How I Met Your Mother, "Belly Full of Turkey" (2005)
... or "Lilly's Thanksgiving from Hell Minnesota." Lily travels to Marshall's family Thanksgiving and, while in the land of frost giants, gets a sneak peek at her cozy, mayo slathered, small town future. Making matters more urgent: she might be pregnant. This one goes out to everyone who knows that a life in the outskirts of the suburbs is not for them, an all too rare sentiment in pop culture.
23. New Girl, "Thanksgiving IV" (2014)
New Girl absolutely needs to be in the conversation when we talk about shows with great Thanksgiving episodes — up there with Friends and Bob's Burgers. After three consecutive turkey day disasters, the gang begrudgingly goes along with Schmidt's (Max Greenfield) idea to celebrate Bangsgiving by setting each other up on blind dates. The big problem: Coach (Damon Wayans Jr.) sets Jess (Zooey Deschanel) up with a guy she actively likes, a guy she works with who she cannot date, per The Rules. Add in a hot lunch monitor, a "Guardian of the Galaxy," Jess' skewed view of Ferris Bueller's Day Off, and Tran, the best silent recurring guest star ever, and you have a winner.
22. Everybody Loves Raymond, "Turkey or Fish" (1996)
Debra (Patricia Heaton) throws down a gauntlet in Season 1's Thanksgiving episode: she wants her Barone household to get in on the dinner hosting rotation. Marie takes great offense to this (of course), and matters only get worse when Debra — conceding that Marie's turkey is hard to beat — decides to make a name for herself with a signature Thanksgiving fish dish. Fish. For Thanksgiving.
21. Bob's Burgers, "Thanks-hoarding" (2017)
Faced with hosting Thanksgiving for his sister, mother, and his mom's boyfriend what's-his-name, a more-frantic-than-usual Teddy (John Murphy) begs Bob and the Belchers to help him get ready. They find a spotless apartment ... until they open a door and discover what was once a dining room now buried under decades of broken junk. Perhaps a dark horse pick for one of this list's Bob's entries (they all can't make it), but Thanks-hoarding is masterful in its realization of holiday anxiety and family trauma. Plus, "I Can Fix It!" is the best Thanksgiving tune since Linda's ditty in "Indecent Thanksgiving Proposal" (#29).
20. WKRP in Cincinnati, "Turkeys Away" (1978)
In the entire history of televised Thanksgiving comedy episodes, precisely two scenes stand out in the public consciousness, passed down from one TV-loving generation to the next. One is higher on this list (no spoilers) and the other unfolds, hauntingly, across the second half of "Turkeys Away." The episode starts with station manager Arthur Carlson (Gordon Jump) trying to find some way to matter at the station. He finds it when he devises a Thanksgiving stunt involving a helicopter and a dozen live turkeys — much to on-the-scene reporter Les Nessman's (Richard Sanders) horror. It's Nessman's reporting that makes this episode so vital to the holiday, a truly perfect melding of writing, line delivery, and performance. You don't see a thing, but you remember every bloody detail. But since the first half of the episode is pretty much entirely void of Thanksgiving, it's hard to place this higher.
19. New Girl, "Thanksgiving" (2011)
New Girl's string of Thanksgiving excellence begins in Season 1, with both feet firmly planted in the show's initial conceit: a trio of dudes (Greenfield, Jake Johnson, Lamorne Morris) trying to disentangle themselves from the twee tendrils of their manic pixie roommate. Case in plot point: Jess fast tracks a Thanksgiving celebration in order to win the heart of her manic pixie coworker Paul (Justin Long). Maybe that all sounds kinda cloying, but the episode works with that, making fun of 2011-era hipster earnestness while exploring everyone's annoying habits. Ultimately everyone is humanized, brought together by the panic of trying to cook a turkey in a drier. This makes for one of the most authentic Friendsgiving portrayals this side of Friends.
18. Bob's Burgers, "Gayle Makin' Bob Sled" (2015)
We all have that one relative. Unfortunately for Bob, that one relative is his sister-in-law (Megan Mullally) and she lives nearby. And when a snowstorm traps the Belcher-mobile in place, Bob is forced to pull a kiddie pool full of chaotic neuroses through a snowstorm for miles. What this episode lacks in turkey-forward humor it more than makes up for in rapid-fire non sequiturs (although watching Linda guess her way through meal prep is hilarious). Megan Mullally should have won an Emmy for this deep dive into Gayle's unsettling psyche.
17. Friends, "The One With Chandler in a Box" (1997)
Desperate to make up for stealing Joey's (Matt LeBlanc) girlfriend, Chandler (Matthew Perry) agrees to spend the day in a box. Don't ask. It makes sense. Joey's reasons are threefold. Latter Friends Thanksgiving episodes get bogged down with truly grating, lazy infighting between the core cast (see Season 7's or Season 10's Thanksgiving episodes for most egregious examples of this). That's what makes Season 4's low-key Thanksgiving entry such a special one: it has conflict baked into its premise, in the episode title, yet this still feels like a show titled Friends. But this conflict is rooted in the love these two dudes have for each other, and it plays out how so many family conflicts play out: against a backdrop of cranberries and stuffing. And I'd be remiss if I did not mention Monica's flirtation with Greek tragedy when she brings home her ex-boyfriend's son as a Thanksgiving date. The writing can hardly be beat ("Judge all you want, but: married a lesbian, left a man at the altar, fell in love with a gay ice dancer, threw a girl's wooden leg in a fire, live in a box!").
16. It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, "The Gang Squashes Their Beefs" (2013)
For some families, Thanksgiving is about setting your differences aside and coming together. For the Reynolds/Kelly/McDonald gestalt, that of course means gathering all of your enemies around one table, setting old differences aside to make room for new, more intense, potentially deadly grievances. This dinner pulls from nine seasons worth of crimes against humanity, serving them with a main course of squash and beef, and then setting it all on fire.
15. Will & Grace, "Moveable Feast" (2001)
The only two-parter on this list — and that's saying something, because sitcoms love using a holiday as an excuse to double the runtime. But this one actually has enough Thanksgiving to fill two episodes — four Thanksgivings, as a matter of fact. Instead of each of the quartet spending all day at a terrible dinner, they all band together and swear to spend one single, solitary hour at each of their four destinations. That's it. There's a kitchen timer and everything. What we get are three storylines with more than enough meat to fill an episode each with A-list guest stars in each playing parents (Blythe Danner, Debbie Reynolds, Beau Bridges), and a character redefining subplot involving Karen coming to terms with having a jailbird husband ("coming to terms" involves boinking a young, hunky Nick Offerman, BTW).
14. The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, "Talking Turkey" (1990)
Will's (Will Smith) mother Vy (Vernee Watson-Johnson) flies in from Philly to spend the holiday with her son, and she doesn't exactly like what she sees. Worried that her sister may have a point about Will getting spoiled in Bel-Air, what with the butler and all, Aunt Viv (Janet Hubert) takes the drastic move of canceling the catered dinner and letting the kids cook the meal. Yes. Hilary, Ashley, and Carlton. Cooking. With Will the de facto head chef (he's the only one who knows where the dishwasher is). This episode does exactly what you want a Thanksgiving sitcom to do: it takes very real familial tensions and filters them through the show's comedic commentary on class, illuminating parts of the series that were previously left in the dark.
13. Friends, "The One Where Underdog Gets Away" (1994)
When the Geller parents skip town for Thanksgiving, Monica steps up to host her first ever Thanksgiving for herself, Ross, and whoever's in town. Then everyone's Big Traditions are suddenly blown up, and these six have to figure out what this very family oriented holiday means when life changes, as it is wont to do, and you have to spend it with, well, your friends. Every character gets a distinct story that feels very being-in-your-20s, and so many little moments are just fantastic ("Otherwise they don't let you do it," "Potatoes are ruined, potatoes are ruined, potatoes are ruined," "Do either of you have the keeey-ees?") It's hard to top Friends' first Thanksgiving episode (but there are still two more Friends eps on the list).
12. All in the Family, "The Little Atheist" (1975)
We've all had a Thanksgiving absolutely derailed by one tiny little comment, right? That's what happens when Archie Bunker (Carroll O'Connor) realizes that his daughter and her meathead husband (Sally Struthers and the late, great Rob Reiner) plan on not raising his grandchild as a Christian. In fact, they aren't gonna raise the kid in a religious household, period! And then, one raspberry towards God's general direction sends Archie over the edge. It's contentious, controversial, awkward, exhausting — truly, All in the Family is the Thanksgiving of sitcoms.
11. Roseanne, "We Gather Together" (1989)
Like the previous Roseanne episode on this list (see #35), "We Gather Together" is a damn fine slice-of-life Thanksgiving episode that puts you right at the table. If you've ever tried to get your parents to stay at a motel, or tried to keep a major life event secret through a round of family interrogation, you'll feel right at home here.
10. New Girl, "Parents" (2012)
Of all the New Girl Thanksgiving episodes, Season 2's "Parents" comes out on top thanks in large part to the debut of Jess's parents, played perfectly by Jamie Lee Curtis and, again, the great Rob Reiner. Jess' attempts to "Parent Trap" them go predictably haywire, and the way Deschanel sells her disappointment at this defeat with a dead-eyed revulsion of all things Thanksgiving is hilarious. But what works is the immediate chemistry Curtis and Reiner have with the entire ensemble. Watching Nick try to sell his zombie novel to Jess' dad, only for Reiner to point out that Nick's essentially written Twilight with zombies, is just one of many endearing moments.
9. Friends, "The One Where Ross Got High" (1999)
I'm amending my earlier statement (see #20) about there being two Thanksgiving scenes that are synonymous with the holiday, because there are actually three. We have to add Rachel's (Jennifer Aniston) unholy English trifle and shepherd's pie mashup to the canon ("It tastes like feet!"). But like the best of latter season Friends, this is a tightly-plotted episode that puts every character to work, from Chandler's desire to be liked by the Gellers to Monica and Ross' sibling bickering. Even Phoebe, who's saddled with a bizarre crush on Mr. Geller (and, later, Jacques Cousteau) shines because Lisa Kudrow can do no wrong. But low key, the MVP is Christina Pickles as Mrs. Geller, and her delivery of the line, "Rachel: No, you weren't supposed to put beef in the trifle. It did not taste good." A real classic, and the second best Friends Thanksgiving episode.
8. That Girl, "Thanksgiving Comes But Once A Year, Hopefully" (1967)
Instead of spending Thanksgiving apart from her boyfriend, Ann (Marlo Thomas) pushes to host the holiday for both her parents and his in her apartment in New York City. What follows is a timeless depiction of madcap dinner prep and bickering families. Marlo Thomas shaking stuffing out of a turkey and into a paper bag is one of the best holiday visuals on this list. It truly captures what it's like to be a young couple navigating Thanksgiving with two sets of particular parents. It's remarkable how timeless (and funny) this episode is 60 years later.
7. 3rd Rock From The Sun, "Gobble Gobble Dick Dick" (1996)
The Solomons experience their first Earth Thanksgiving, and it is a riot. There's nothing sentimental about it. This episode is a joke machine that lampoons the stress and madness associated with the holiday. But the real reason this cracks the top ten? Jan Hooks' ferociously horny performance as the landlady's daughter, Vicki. The scene where she comes on to Harry (French Stewart) using nothing but a table of leftovers is quite possibly the funniest scene on this entire list involving a turkey carcass.
6. Will & Grace, "Homo For the Holidays" (1999)
And on the emotional side of things, we have Will & Grace — a show known for being acerbic over sentimental. In its first Thanksgiving episode, Will & Grace tackled a holiday tradition that had most likely never been seen on TV before: coming out of the closet on Thanksgiving. Somehow, flamboyant Jack (Sean Hayes) had not yet come out to his mother ("What is she, headless?"). Never mind the fact that he's, y'know, Jack. (But also, the American public at large "did not know" that Sean Hayes was gay at the time. What were we, headless?) This episode strikes a fantastic balance between the nonstop, merciless wit that so defined early Will & Grace and a surprising, empathetic tenderness — not so much between Jack and his mother (the iconic Veronica Cartwright), but between Will and Jack.
5. Bob's Burgers, "Turkey in a Can" (2013)
I've shared a lot of my opinions. For this, Bob's Burgers' highest appearance on this list, I'm turning it over to Matthew Jackson, who also rated this as the best of Bob's Burgers's Thanksgiving episodes in his own list last year:
There is so much going on in "Turkey in a Can" that it almost feels like it won't fit in a 22-minute sitcom episode. Gayle's staying at the Belchers' house for Thanksgiving, Bob's trying a new turkey recipe, Gene's writing a new Thanksgiving song, and Tina's trying her best to make it to the adults' table. When Bob's raw, still-brining turkey ends up in the toilet, it launches a mad whodunit mixed with one man's desperate attempt to actually get Thanksgiving dinner on the table, and on top of all of that, it introduces us to the wonders of Bisexual Bob. The ultimate message? You can't halt the march of the time as your family grows and changes, but you can still be there for them, and that's the true perfect Thanksgiving. This one's not just the best Bob's Burgers Thanksgiving episode. It's up there with the best Thanksgiving episodes of any show ever, and it's great to watch with Bob's Burgers newbies too.
4. Friends, "The One With The Football" (1996)
The best of Friends' Thanksgiving episodes. The premise is simple: the gang plays touch football on Thanksgiving Day (in between basting the turkey). That's it. But, line for line, minute by minute, this is quite possibly the funniest episode of Friends, period ("You dated a guy with a glass eye too?!"). Season 3's Thanksgiving episode hits at the show's absolute creative peak, and — from a technical standpoint — it's an absolute miracle to behold. The show built an entire NYC park on a soundstage for this episode, populating it with extras and capturing the ambiance of New York in the fall while indoors in front of an audience. The episode, famously expensive, is why the bottle episode "The One Where No One's Ready" exists (and that might be the second funniest episode of the show).
But this episode, deceptively simple, is still working within the season's larger character arcs. This is the episode where Chandler gets his groove back after being dumped ("The ball is Janice, the ball is Janice!"), and it continues to show the cracks in Ross and Rachel's relationship ("You don't pick me, you're stuck with me!"). And all the while, it scores laughs not only with excellent jokes ("I went really long."), razor sharp character moments ("Math?! You're giving me math?!"), and some of the series' best physical comedy moments (how many people does it take to stop Joey from scoring a touchdown?). This is a Thanksgiving miracle.
3. Mad About You, "Giblets for Murray" (1994)
There are a few recurring themes spread out across the 60 years of television captured on this list. Two of them are: the mile-a-minute, exquisitely choreographed physical comedy romp of hosting a dinner; and the struggles of a character (or a couple) hosting their first Thanksgiving. "Giblets for Murray" is the absolute best of both worlds.
It's the Buchmans' first time hosting Thanksgiving, and they have so many people to please. Multiple opinions on cranberries, stuffing, whether to make or buy ice, whether or not someone's a real vegetarian or just trying to piss off their father — it's a nightmare that's made even worse when the turkey ends up in Murray's belly (see: above). Paul and Jamie are then tasked with securing a new turkey on Thanksgiving Day — which then disappears ("Never leave a turkey in a hallway in New York City!"), and then disappears again, and again (in ways that I won't spoil). This episode is packed full of laugh-out-loud moments, callbacks, and runners ("Yes you do... yes you do... yes you do...") — it's a veritable buffet of jokes. Holding it all together are Paul Reiser and Helen Hunt, two of the best to ever do it, two people who don't get enough flowers for the brisk realism they brought to the sitcom format.
2. The Bob Newhart Show, "Over the River and Through the Woods" (1975)
After Bob (Bob Newhart) twists his way out of going to his wife Emily's (Suzanne Pleshette) family Thanksgiving in Seattle, he ends up trapped in the midst of one of the most ramshackle Thanksgiving "celebrations" on the list. Just him, his jackass [complimentary] of a coworker Jerry (Peter Bonerz), his flighty neighbor Howard (Bill Daily), and his misanthropic, perhaps sociopathic patient Elliot (Jack Riley).
And here it is, the other seminal Thanksgiving episode (see: #20) that has been at the top of lists like this one since long before Friends even debuted. The drunk scene is one of the most intricate and hilariously executed scenes in not just Thanksgiving sitcom history, but sitcom history. Newhart's widely lauded as a deadpan actor, but his secret weapon is just how good he is at playing drunk, with a sleepy-eyed delirium. Is it really Thanksgiving if you don't hear Bob slur "More goo to go"?
1. Cheers, "Thanksgiving Orphans" (1986)
When the entire lineup of regulars realizes they're going to be alone on Thanksgiving, they all band together to form a Thanksgiving at Carla's (Rhea Perlman). And — you guessed it — things don't pan out. Cliff (John Ratzenberger) brings his leftover popcorn balls, Frasier keeps pivoting to see the TV, Sam (Ted Danson) shows up to the dinner stag, and the at-times snooty Diane (Shelley Long) ends up on Carla's doorstep (in full pilgrim regalia). Things go from "meh" to "oh my god" when the main dish keeps getting delayed (the turkey's pop thing won't pop) and everyone gets so hangry that they begin to revolt. Cue: food fight, with all the cold, uneaten food gathering dust on the table.
This episode is exactly what this holiday is about. Not a food fight, but found family — especially the kind of family that you don't even know is there until you're all sat around a table, covered in icy taters and pudding skin. On every other day, these people are just co-workers, patrons, servers, and bar regulars to each other. You don't measure family by the number of minutes you spend in another person's presence. But when this group of people are pulled out of the bar, they find that while they've been grinding through the days, year after year, they've all come to mean way, way more to each other. They're united by more than just the bar. They're united by a shared human experience and — whether they cop to it or not on the other 364 days of the year — a natural pull towards each other. They are spending Thanksgiving with family. This is a hilarious, messy, perfect, beautiful statement on what it means to be human.
And it's the only food fight that will also make you cry (the good kind of crying).









